±Æ»³Ë¡Î§Æõö»ö̳½ê
¥Û¡¼¥à¥Ú¡¼¥¸
Kagelaw Homepage
© 2005 Kotaro Kageyama



































ÊÛ¸î»Î¡¦ÊÛÍý»Î¤Î·ÐÎò
ÊÛ¸î»Î¡¦ÊÛÍý»Î¡¡±Æ»³¡¡¸÷ÂÀϺ
·ÐÎò¡ÊÊ¿À®30ǯ¸½ºß¡Ë
Ê¿À®12ǯ¡Á¸½ºß¡¡·§ËÜÂç³ØµÒ°÷¶µ¼ø¡ÊÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡Ë
Ê¿À®27ǯ¡Á¸½ºß¡¡ÅìËÌÂç³Ø¡¦Ì¤Íè²Ê³Øµ»½Ñ¶¦Æ±¸¦µæ¥»¥ó¥¿¡¼¡¦¥·¥Ë¥¢¥ê¥µ¡¼¥Á¡¦¥Õ¥§¥í¡¼
Ê¿À®10ǯ¡Á¸½ºß¡¡ÆüËÜÃÎŪºâ»ºÃçºÛ¥»¥ó¥¿¡¼Ä´Ää¿Í¸õÊä¼Ô¡¦ÃçºÛ¿Í¸õÊä¼Ô¡¦È½Äê¿Í¸õÊä¼Ô
Ê¿À®17ǯ¡Á¸½ºß¡¡ºâÃÄË¡¿ÍÃÎŪ»ñ»º³èÍÑ¥»¥ó¥¿¡¼´Æ»ö

¿¦Îò
Ê¿À®20¡Á29ǯ¡¡ÂçʬÂç³ØµÒ°÷¶µ¼ø¡ÊÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡Ë
Ê¿À®20¡Á28ǯ¡¡ºùÈþÎÓÂç³ØÆÃǤ¶µ¼ø¡ÊÂç³ØÅùºÆ·úË¡¡¢ÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡Ë
Ê¿À®23¡Á25ǯ¡¡·²ÇÏÂç³ØµÒ°÷¶µ¼ø(ÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡Ë
Ê¿À®18¡Á19ǯ¡¡Í㥷¥¹¥Æ¥à³ô¼°²ñ¼ÒÂåɽ¼èÄùÌò²ñĹ
Ê¿À®15¡Á18ǯ¡¡ÅìËÌÂç³ØµÒ°÷¶µ¼ø¡ÊÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡Ë
Ê¿À®16¡Á17ǯ¡¡³Ø¹»Ë¡¿ÍÅìËÌʸ²½³Ø±àÂç³ØÍý»öĹ¡¦³Ø¹»Ë¡¿Íͧ°¦³Ø±àÍý»öĹ¡¢ÅìËÌʸ²½³Ø±àÂç³ØµÒ°÷¶µ¼ø¡ÊÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡Ë
Ê¿À®15¡Á16ǯ¡¡ºë¶ÌÂç³ØÈó¾ï¶Ð¹Ö»Õ¡Ê²ñ¼ÒÅùºÆ·úË¡¡Ë
Ê¿À®£¹¡Á15ǯ¡¡ÀéÍÕ¹©¶ÈÂç³ØÈó¾ï¶Ð¹Ö»Õ¡ÊÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡Ë
»º¶ÈºàÎÁÄ´ºº¸¦µæ½ê¶Ð̳¡¢°°¾Ë»Ò³ô¼°²ñ¼Ò¶Ð̳

³ØÎò
ÅìµþÂç³Ø¹©³Ø·ÏÂç³Ø±¡¹©¶È²½³ØÀ칶½¤»Î²ÝÄø½¤Î»¡¢ÅìµþÂç³Ø
¹©³ØÉô¹çÀ®²½³Ø²Ê´¶È¡¢Åìµþ¶µ°éÂç³Ø¡Ê¸½¡¦ÃÞÇÈÂç³Ø¡ËÉí°¹â¹»Â´¶È

½ê°³Ø²ñ
¼ÒÃÄË¡¿ÍÆüËܲ½³Ø²ñ


»ñ³Ê
ÊÛ¸î»ÎÅÐÏ¿¡Ê¾¼ÏÂ57ǯ¡Ë¡¢ÊÛÍý»ÎÅÐÏ¿¡Ê¾¼ÏÂ59ǯ¡Ë¡¢¸ø³²ËɻߴÉÍý¼ÔÂ絤´Ø·¸Âè°ì¼ï¡¢¿å¼Á´Ø·¸Âè°ì¼ï¡¢´í¸±Êª¼è°·¼çǤ¡¢¹â¹»¶µ°÷Ìȵö°ìµé¡ÊÍý²Ê¡¢¹©¶È¡Ë¡¢Á´¾¦Êíµ­¸¡Äê°ìµé

ÊÝÍ­Æõö
(1)¡ÖÈùÀ¸ÊªÁý¿£ÍÞÀ©ºîÍѤòÍ­¤¹¤ë¥ê¥ó»ÀµÛÃåÀ­³°ÍѺޡ¢¤½¤ì¤ò´ÞÍ­¤¹¤ëÀ½ÉʵڤӤ½¤ÎÀ½Â¤ÊýË¡¡×
ÆõöÅÐÏ¿Èֹ桧¡¡ÆõöÂ裳£¹£¹£µ£°£µ£²¹æ
¹ñºÝ½Ð´êNo.¡§¡¡PCT/JP2006/312966

(2)¡ÖÈùÀ¸ÊªÃ±Î¥¼èÆÀ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Î¥Þ¥¤¥¯¥í¡¦¥Þ¥Ë¥Ô¥å¥ì¡¼¥¿ÁõÃåÍÑÈù¾®¹©¶ñ¡×
ÆõöÅÐÏ¿Èֹ桧¡¡ÆõöÂ裴£±£µ£²£´£²£¹¹æ

(3)¡ÖºÙ˦ñΥˡ¡×
ÆõöÅÐÏ¿Èֹ桧¡¡ÆõöÂ裴£¶£·£µ£´£±£µ¹æ

(4)¡ÖÇòµÂËɽüºÞ¡×
ÆõöÅÐÏ¿Èֹ桧¡¡ÆõöÂ裵£´£µ£µ£µ£µ£¶¹æ


½ÐÈÇ
(1)¡Ö
Calorimetric and X-ray Studies of Glassy and Crystalline Inorganic Polymer:Arsenic Trisulfide (As£²S£³)¡×¡¡Reports on Progress in Polymer Physics in Japan Vol.XII 1969.
(2)¡Ö´ë²è³«È¯Éô°÷¤ÎˡΧ¼Â̳¡×¡¡·Ð±Äˡ̳¡Ê¾¼ÏÂ60ǯ£¹·î¹æ¡ÁÊ¿À®£²Ç¯£¶·î¹æ¡Ë
(3)¡Ö¼Â̳¤ËÌòΩ¤ÄÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡×¡¡ÆüËܼ¶ȽÐÈÇ¡ÊÊ¿À®14ǯ£²·î¡Ë
(4)¡Ö´ë¶ÈºÆ·ú¤ÈÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¡×¡¡¡Ø´ë¶ÈºÆ·ú¤Î¿¿¿ñ¡ÙÀ¶¿åľ¡¡¾¦»öˡ̳¡¡¡ÊÊ¿À®17ǯ£µ·î¡Ë
(5)¡ÖȯÌÀ¼Ô¤ÎǧÄê¤È¼ý±×¤Ø¤ÎÆõöȯÌÀ¤Î´óÍ¿¡Ý¿¦Ì³È¯ÌÀ¤Ë¤â´ØÏ¢¤·¤Æ¡Ý¡×¡¡Ãκâ´ÉÍý¡ÊÊ¿À®18ǯ£¶·î¹æ¡Ë
(6)¡Ö³ØÀ¸¤ÎȯÌÀ¤È¿¦Ì³È¯ÌÀ¡×¥Ñ¥Æ¥ó¥È¡ÊVol.60¡¡Ê¿À®19ǯ£¹·î¹æ¡Ë
(7)¡ÖȯÌÀ¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©µÚ¤ÓȯÌÀ¼Ô¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼Ô¤ÎǧÄê¡Ý½¾Íè¤ÎȯÌÀÀ®Î©²áÄø¤Î£²Ãʳ¬ÏÀ¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Î¹Í»¡¤ò´Þ¤á¤Æ¡Ý¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.6¡¡No.66¡¡Ê¿À®20ǯ£³·î¹æ¡Ë
(8)¡ÖȯÌÀ¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©¤ª¤è¤ÓȯÌÀ¼Ô¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼Ô¤ÎǧÄê¤È¤³¤ì¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯È½Îã¤Î¸¡Æ¤¡×£Î£Â£Ì¡ÊNo.886¡¡Ê¿À®20ǯ£¸·î¡Ë
(9)¡Ö¸¦µæ¥Æ¡¼¥Þ¤ÎÄ󼨤ÈȯÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©¡¦È¯ÌÀ¼Ô¤ÎǧÄê¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.7¡¡No.73¡¡Ê¿À®20ǯ10·î¹æ¡Ë
(10)¡ÖȯÌÀ¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©¤ÈȯÌÀ¼Ô¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼ÔǧÄê¤Î´ð½à¡¦ÊýË¡¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.7¡¡No.76¡¡Ê¿À®21ǯ£±·î¹æ¡Ë
(11)¡ÖÃÎŪ»ñ»º·Ð±Ä¤ÎˡΧÃμ±¡ÝÃÎŪºâ»ºË¡¤Î¼Â̳¤È¹Í¤¨Êý¡×»°Ï½ñÀÒ¡ÊÊ¿À®21ǯ£¹·î¡Ë
(12)¡Ö»ö¶ÈºÆÀ¸¤ÎˡΧÃμ±¡Ý̱»öºÆÀ¸Ë¡¤òÃæ¿´¤È¤·¤¿¼Â̳¤È¹Í¤¨Êý¡Ý¡×»°Ï½ñÀÒ¡ÊÊ¿À®22ǯ£¶·î¡Ë
(13)¡Ö
Formation of Invention / Joint Invention and Recognition of Inventor / Joint Inventor¡×(Journal of Intellectual Property Law and Practice, Vol.5, No.10, 2010 Oxford Journal)
(14)¡Öº®Æ٤λþÂå¤òÂó¤¯Íý·ÏÊÛ¸î»Î¤ÎÀ¸¤­Êý¡¦¸«Êý¡×¹ÖÃ̼ҽÐÈÇ¥µ¡¼¥Ó¥¹¥»¥ó¥¿¡¼¡ÊÊ¿À®23ǯ£´·î¡Ë
(15)¡ÖȯÌÀ¼Ô¡¿¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼ÔǧÄê¤ÎÄ󼨤·¤¿´ð½à¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯È½·è½ñ¤Î½ñ¤­ÊýµÚ¤ÓÁʾ٤ο³Íý¤Î¤·Êý¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.9¡¡No.105¡¡Ê¿À®23ǯ£¶·î¹æ¡Ë
(16)¡Ö¼Â¸³¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆȯÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©¤¹¤ë²áÄø¤Î¹Í»¡¤ÈȯÌÀ¼Ô¤ÎǧÄê¡ÝÆõö½Ð´ê¤ÈÏÀʸȯɽ¤Î´Ø·¸¤â´Þ¤á¤Æ¡Ý¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.9¡¡No.108¡¡Ê¿À®23ǯ£¹·î¹æ¡Ë
(17)¡ÖȯÌÀ¼Ô¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼ÔǧÄêµÚ¤Ó´óÍ¿³ä¹ç¤Î»»Äê¤ÎÄêÎ̲½¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.10¡¡No.111¡¡Ê¿À®23ǯ12·î¹æ¡Ë
(18)¡ÖȯÌÀ¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀÀ®Î©¤ÎʬÀϵڤÓȯÌÀ¼Ô¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼ÔǧÄê¤È´óÍ¿³ä¹ç»»Äê¤Î¼ê°ú¤­¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.10¡¡No.113¡¡Ê¿À®24ǯ£²·î¹æ¡Ë
(19)¡Ö¸¦µæ¥Æ¡¼¥Þ¤ÎȯÌÀ¤Ø¤Î´óÍ¿¤Îɾ²Á¡ÝȯÌÀ¡¿¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©Ãʳ¬¤ÎʬÀϤ˴ð¤Å¤¯¡×¡ÊVol.10¡¡No.117¡¡Ê¿À®24ǯ£¶·î¹æ¡Ë
(20)¡Ö
The practice of recognizing an inventor/joint inventors and calculation of contribution ratios among joint inventors¡×¡ÊJournal of Intellectual Property Law and Practice, Vol.7, No.8, 2012 Oxford Journal) Link
(21)¡ÖȯÌÀ¡¿¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©¤È¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼Ô¤ÎǧÄ꤫¤éɾ²Á¡¦½è¶ø¤Ø¡Ý °ìÈÌ¡¦¼Â¸³¡¦¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¤Î¾ì¹ç¤ÎȯÌÀ¼ÔǧÄê¤È¶¦Æ±È¯ÌÀ¼Ô´Ö¤Î´óÍ¿³ä¹ç»»Äê¤Î´ð½à¡¦¼ê½ç ¡Ý¡×·ÐºÑ»º¶ÈÄ´ºº²ñ¡¡Ê¿À®24ǯ
(22)¡ÖÀ½Â¤ÊýË¡¤òµ­ºÜ¤·¤¿¥¯¥ì¡¼¥à¡Ê¥×¥í¥À¥¯¥È¡¦¥Ð¥¤¡¦¥×¥í¥»¥¹¡¦¥¯¥ì¡¼¥à¡Ë¤ÎɬÍ×À­¤È¹çÍýÀ­¤Ë¤è¤ë¸ÂÄê¡¡¡ÝʪÂηϡ¦Êª¼Á·Ï¤ÎȯÌÀ¤ÎʬÎàµÚ¤ÓȯÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©¤Ë¡Ê°ì±þ¤Î¡Ë¸¶Íý¤«¤é¤Îͽ¬Æñ°×À­¤ò¹Í¤¨¤ë¸«²ò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯¡Ý¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à(Vol.11 No.128 2013ǯ£µ·î¹æ¡Ë
(23)¡ÖÀ½Â¤ÊýË¡¤òµ­ºÜ¤·¤¿¥¯¥ì¡¼¥à¡Ê¥×¥í¥À¥¯¥È¡¦¥Ð¥¤¡¦¥×¥í¥»¥¹¡¦¥¯¥ì¡¼¥à¡Ë¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëʪ¤ÎƱ°ìÀ­¤ÎȽÃÇ ¡ÝȯÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©¤Ë¡Ê°ì±þ¤Î¡Ë¸¶Íý¤«¤é¤Îͽ¬Æñ°×À­¤ò¹Í¤¨¤ë¸«²ò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯¡Ý¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.11, No.131¡¢2013ǯ£¸·î¹æ¡Ë
(24)¡Ö¥×¥í¥À¥¯¥È¡¦¥Ð¥¤¡¦¥×¥í¥»¥¹¡¦¥¯¥ì¡¼¥à¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëȯÌÀ¤ÎÍ×»ÝǧÄê¡¢µ»½ÑŪÈϰϤβò¼á¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤ÆʪƱ°ìÀâµÚ¤ÓÀ½Ë¡¸ÂÄêÀâ¤ÎŬÍÑÅù¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¹Í»¡¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.11, No.134¡¡2013ǯ11·î¹æ¡Ë
(25)¡ÖNecessity, Criteria (Requirements or Limits) and Acknowledgement of Product Identity of Claims for Product Described by Its Manufacturing Process (Product-by-Process Claims)¡×(Beijing Law Review Vol.5, No.2 June 2014) Link
(26)¡Ö¾ï¼±¤«¤éˡΧ¾ï¼±¤Ø¡ÝÆüËÜË¡¤Î´ðÁؤÎÍý²ò¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¡Ý¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.12, No.142, 2014ǯ£µ·î¹æ¤«¤éVol.13, No.152, 2015ǯ£µ·î¹æ¤Þ¤Ç(1)¡Á(13)¤ÎÏ¢ºÜ¡Ë

(27)¡Ö¾ï¼±¤«¤éˡΧ¾ï¼±¤Ø ¡ÝÆüËÜË¡¤Î´ðÁؤ«¤é¤Î¤â¤¦¤Ò¤È¤Ä¤ÎˡΧÆþÌç¡Ý¡×·ÐºÑ»º¶ÈÄ´ºº²ñ¡ÊÊ¿À®27ǯ£··î¡Ë
(28)¡Ö
Recognition of Inventor/Joint Inventors and Product-by-Process Claims¡×LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing (Germany, Oct. 2015).
(29)¡ÖȯÌÀÀ®Î©²áÄø¡Ê¸¶Íý¡Ë¤ò¹Í¤¨¤¿¿ÊÊâÀ­¤ÎȽÃÇ´ð½à¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.14, No.162, 2016ǯ£³·î¹æ¡Ë
(30)¡ÖȯÌÀ¤ÎʬÎࡢȯÌÀ¤ÎÀ®Î©²áÄø(¸¶Íý)¤ò¹Í¤¨¤¿ÆõöȯÌÀ¤Î¶ÑÅùÏÀ¤ò´Þ¤àµ»½ÑŪÈÏ°Ï¡¢Æõö¿¯³²ÁʾÙÅù¤Î¹Í»¡¡Ý¹½Â¤ÅªµÚ¤Ó¼ê³Ū»ëÅÀ¤«¤é¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.14, No.167, 2016ǯ£¸·î¹æ¡Ë
(31)¡Ö
Determining Inventive Step or Nonobviousness for a Patent Requirement in View of the Formation Process of an Invention¡×(Beijing Law Review Vol.7, No.3 September 2016) Link
(32)¡ÖStudy of Technical Scope Including Doctrine of Equivalent and Patent Infringement Litigation¡×(International Journal of Case Studies Vol.5, Issue 11 November 2016) Link
(33)¡ÖʪÂηϤÎȯÌÀ¤Èʪ¼Á·Ï¤ÎȯÌÀ¡ÝȯÌÀ¤Îɽ¤ìÊý¡Ê³°´Ñ¡¦À­¼Á¡Ë¤«¤é¤ÎʬÎà¤Î¸úÍÑ¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.15, No.171, 2016ǯ12·î¹æ¡Ë
(34)
¡ÖʪÂηϵڤÓʪ¼Á·Ï¤ÎȯÌÀ¡¦µ»½Ñ¤Î¹¹¤Ê¤ë¹Í»¡¡ÝȯÌÀ¤Î¤·Êý¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¥È¥¥¥ê¡¼¥º¤È¤Î´Ø·¸¤â´Þ¤á¤Æ¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à¡ÊVol.15, No.175, 2017ǯ£´·î¹æ¡Ë
(35)¡Öµ»½Ñ¤«¤éȯÌÀ¤òÆÀ¤ë¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡Ø¸¶Íý¤ÎÍøÍѤȤ½¤Î¤·Êý¡Ù¤«¤é¤Î¹Í»¡Ž£ Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à Vol.15, No.179, 1-30ÊÇ2017ǯ£¸·î¹æ
(36)¡ÖPhysical-Object Invention and the Material Invention - Efficient Use of a Categorization Based on Looks (Appearance and Property)¡×(Beijing Law Review Vol.8, No.3 September 2017) Link
(37)¡ÖÅý°ìŪ¤Ë¹Í¤¨¤ë¿ÊÊâÀ­¤È¥¯¥ì¡¼¥à²ò¼á¡Ý¡ØʪÍý¡¦²½³Ø¤Î¸¶Íý¤È¤½¤ÎÍøÍѤΤ·Êý¡Ù¤È¡ØʪÂηϡ¦Êª¼Á·Ï¤ÎȯÌÀ¤ÎʬÎà¡Ù¤«¤é¡×°ìÈ̺âÃÄË¡¿Í¡¡·ÐºÑ»º¶ÈÄ´ºº²ñ¡¡Ê¿À®29ǯ11·î
(38)¡ÖAnalysis of TRIZ's Invention Principles¡× (The Triz Journal, January 23, 2018) Link
(39)¡ÖUnified Approach for Inventive Step and Claim Interpretation¡×LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing (Germany, June 2018).
(40) Ž¢ÆõöË¡¾å¤ÎÌäÂê²òÌÀ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Î¼Â¸³¤Ë¤è¤ëȯÌÀ¤ÎʬÀÏ-Ž¢¸¶Íý¤È¤½¤ÎÍøÍÑŽ£µÚ¤ÓŽ¢Êª¤Î·Á¾õŽ¥¹½Â¤Ž¥ÊªÀ­¤È¤½¤ÎÊѲ½Ž£¤Ë¤è¤ëȯÌÀ¤ÎÃê¾Ý²½¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯-Ž£ Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à Vol.16, No.190, 1-26ÊÇ¡¡2018ǯ£··î¹æ
(41)¡Ö¥È¥¥¥ê¡¼¥º¤ÎȯÌÀ¸¶Íý¤Îº¬µò¡¦ÇÛÎó¤È¤½¤ÎÍøÍѤΤ·Êý¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Î¹Í»¡¡Ýʪ¤Î·Á¾õ¡¦¹½Â¤¡¦ÊªÀ­µÚ¤Ó¸¶Íý¡¦¸¶Íý¤ÎÍøÍÑ¡¦ÍøÍѤΤ·Êý¤«¤é¤ÎÆ󼡸µÅªÊ¬ÀϤ˴ð¤Å¤¯-Ž£ Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à Vol.16, No.192, 1-20ÊÇ¡¡2018ǯ£¹·î¹æ
(42) Ž¢¿ÊÊâÀ­¤ÎÂоݤÎõµæ¤È¿³ºº´ð½à¤Ë±è¤Ã¤¿È½ÃǤμê½ç¤ÎÊäÀ⎣ Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à Vol.17, No.194, 1-31ÊÇ¡¡2018ǯ11·î¹æ
(43)¡Ö¿ÊÊâÀ­¡¦¥¯¥ì¡¼¥à²ò¼á¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÁ´ÂΤÈÉôʬ¤ò¹Íθ¤·¤¿Ãê¾Ý²½¤Î´ð½à¡Ê¸¶Íý¡¦ÍøÍÑ¡¢£¶¤Ä¤ÎÍ×°ø¡Ë¤ÎÍѤ¤Êý¡×Ãκâ¤×¤ê¤º¤à Vol.17, No.197, 1-30ÊÇ¡¡2019ǯ£²·î¹æ
(44)¡Ö
Invention and Comparison of Patenting and Examination Guidelines about Inventive Step in Japan, the U.S.A. and the EU - based on the Opinion Focusing on Principles and Their Use¡×(Beijing Law Review Vol.10, No.3 June 2019)Link

¼è°·»ö·ï
I. ̱»ö»ö·ïµÚ¤ÓÃÎŪºâ»º¸¢»ö·ï¡Ê´©¹Ôʪ·ÇºÜ°Æ·ï¤«¤éÈ´¿è¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Î¤ß¡Ë
(1)Åìµþ¹âÅùºÛȽ½ê¡¡Ê¿À®£µÇ¯£¹·î£¹Æü·èÄê¡ÊȽÎã»þÊó1485¹æp.116¡Ë
¡¡Æõö¸¢¿¯³²»ö·ï¤ÎºÛȽ´É³í¤¬Áè¤ï¤ì¤¿»öÎã
(2)¾¾»³ÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê¡¡Ê¿À®£¸Ç¯11·î19Æü·èÄê¡¡(ȽÎã»þÊó1608¹æp.139)
¡¡Æõö¸¢¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÀè»ÈÍѸ¢¤ÎÈϰϤˤĤ¤¤Æ¤Î»öÎã
(3)ÅìµþÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê¡¡Ê¿À®10ǯ£µ·î22ÆüȽ·è¡Ê¶âͻˡ̳»ö¾ð1540¹æp.67¡Ë
¡¡ÇËþ¶âÍ»µ¡´Ø¤ÎºÄ¸¢¾ùÅÏÅù·èµÄ¤Ï̱ˡÂè398¾ò¥Î20­¡¹à°ì¤Î³ÎÄê»öͳ¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿»öÎã
(4)ÅìµþÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê¡¡Ê¿À®10ǯ10·î£·ÆüȽ·è¡ÊȽÎ㥿¥¤¥à¥º987¹æp.255¡Ë
¡¡£Á¡¡ÆõöÀÁµá¤ÎÈϰϤˤĤ¤¤Æ¤Î¶ÑÅùÏÀ¤¬ÈÝÄꤵ¤ì¤¿»öÎã
¡¡£Â¡¡Æõö¸¢¿¯³²¼Ô¤ÎÆÀ¤¿Íø±×³Û¤Î»»½ÐÊýË¡¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Î»öÎã
(5)ÅìµþÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê¡¡Ê¿À®14ǯ£´·î15ÆüȽ·è¡ÊȽÎ㥿¥¤¥à¥º1098¹æp.213¡¢È½Îã»þÊó1792¹æp.129¡Ë
¡¡Åìµþ¹âÅùºÛȽ½ê¡¡Ê¿À®14ǯ10·î29ÆüȽ·è¡ÊºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¥Û¡¼¥à¥Ú¡¼¥¸·ÇºÜ¡Ë
¡¡¥Û¡¼¥à¥Ú¡¼¥¸¤Îµ­»ö¤ÎÅê¹Æ¼Ô¤ËÃøºî¸¢¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤¿»öÎã
(6)ÅìµþÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê¡¡Ê¿À®16ǯ£³·î£µÆüȽ·è¡ÊȽÎã»þÊó1854¹æp.153¡¢¾¦»öˡ̳1704¹æȽp.2258¡Ë
¡¡Å¹ÊÞ½êºß¤ÎÃÏ̾¤Î»ÈÍѤ¬ÉÔÀµ¶¥Áè¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿»öÎã
(7)Åìµþ¹âºÛÊ¿À®16ǯ10·î13ÆüȽ·è(ȽÎ㥿¥¤¥à¥º1181¹æp132)
¡¡º¾³²¹Ô°Ù¼è¾ÃÀÁµá(ÈÝǧ¸¢)¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤¿»öÎã¡£ºÇ¹âºÛÊ¿À®17ǯ11·î18ÆüȽ·è¤Ç¤âǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤¿¡£
(8)Åìµþ¹âÅùºÛȽ½êÊ¿À®19ǯ£³·î14ÆüȽ·è¡ÊȽÎ㥿¥¤¥à¥º1246¹æp.337¡Ë
¡¡£Á¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©¤òÍýͳ¤Ë¥ê¡¼¥¹·ÀÌó¤Î²ò½ü¤Ï¤Ç¤­¤Ê¤¤¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿»öÎã
¡¡£Â¡¡¥ê¡¼¥¹·ÀÌó²ò½ü¸å¡¢ÌÜŪʪ¤ÎÉÔÊִԤˤè¤ë»³²Çå½þºÄ¸¢¤Ï¶¦±×ºÄ¸¢¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿»öÎã
(9)ÂçºåÃϺÛÊ¿À®25ǯ10·î17ÆüȽ·è(ºÇ¹âºÛ¥Û¡¼¥à¥Ú¡¼¥¸·ÇºÜ)
¡¡¾¦ÉʤÎÉʼÁɽ¼¨¤Ë¶á¤¤³°¹ñ¸ì¤Î¾¦É¸¸¢¤Î¹Ô»È¤ò¸¢ÍøÍðÍѤȤ·¤¿»öÎã

II. ²ñ¼ÒºÆ·ú´Ø·¸¡Ê¼çÍװƷ狼¤éÈ´¿è¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Î¤ß¡Ë
¾¼ÏÂ60ǯ¡¡­ëÀéÀкÇË»º´Éºâ¿Í
Ê¿À®£³Ç¯¡¡­êÅìµþ¥È¥é¥Ù¥ë¥»¥ó¥¿¡¼¡¡ÇË»º´Éºâ¿Í
Ê¿À®£·Ç¯¡¡Î빯¥°¥ë¡¼¥×¡ÊÎ빯»º¶È­ê¡¢Î빯¥³¥¤¥ë¥¹¥Á¡¼¥ë­ê¡¢
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡Î빯ÉÔÆ°»º­ê¾£·¼Ò¡Ë¡¡ÊÝÁ´´ÉÍý¿ÍÂåÍý
Ê¿À®£·Ç¯¡¡Æ±¾å¡¡¹¹À¸´Éºâ¿ÍÂåÍý
Ê¿À®10ǯ¡¡»°°æÉÖƬ­ê¡¡²ñ¼Ò¹¹À¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
Ê¿À®12ǯ¡¡­ê¥¢¥Ù¡¦¥¤¥ó¥¿¡¼¥Ê¥·¥ç¥Ê¥ë¡¦¥Ù¥ó¥Á¥ã¡¼¥º¡¦¥³¡¼¥Ý¥ì¡¼¥·¥ç¥ó¡¢
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥¢¡¼¥È¥×¥é¥¶¥»¥ó¡¡ÆÃÊÌÀ¶»»¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í¡¢À¶»»¿Í¾ïÃÖÂåÍý¿Í
Ê¿À®12ǯ¡¡­ê»°ÅÄ¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
Ê¿À®13ǯ¡¡¥µ¥ó¥Ð¡¼¥¹¥È­ê¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
Ê¿À®14ǯ¡¡Ë̤βȲ­ê¡¢¤Ï¤»¤¬¤ï¥¤¥ó¥¿¡¼¥Ê¥·¥ç¥Ê¥ë­ê¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
Ê¿À®14ǯ¡¡­êµ×²æ²°¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
Ê¿À®15ǯ¡¡ÂçÀö­ê¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
Ê¿À®15ǯ¡¡­êºØ·û¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
Ê¿À®16ǯ¡¡µþ»°·úÀß¹©¶È­ê¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ëÆü²Ö¾¦»ö¡¡Ì±»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ÅìËÌʸ²½³Ø±àÂç³Ø¡¦Í§°¦³Ø±àÍý»öĹ¡Ê¡ÁH17.3¡Ë
Ê¿À®17ǯ¡¡­êÅ´¹ü¥­¥ã¥É¡¦¥­¥ã¥à¥»¥ó¥¿¡¼ÇË»º´Éºâ¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥¼¥¯¡¼ÊÝÁ´´ÉÍý¿Í¡¢Æ±ÇË»º´Éºâ¿Í
Ê¿À®18ǯ¡¡­ê¥Ó¥¯¥È¥ê¡¼Ì±»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡Í㥷¥¹¥Æ¥à­êÂåɽ¼èÄùÌò²ñĹ¡Ê¡ÁÊ¿À®19ǯ£¶·î¡Ë
Ê¿À®19ǯ¡¡­ê¶¨ÏÂ¥³¥ó¥¿¥¯¥È̱»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­êºä°æ¾¦²ṉ̃»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥¨¥¯¥¹¥×¥í¡¼¥é¡¼¥³¡¼¥Ý¥ì¡¼¥·¥ç¥ó̱»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
Ê¿À®20ǯ¡¡­êÊ¿ÎÓ¶âʪẔ́»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥´¡¼¥¤¥ó¥°ÇË»º´Éºâ¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥¹¥Þ¡¼¥È¥Ó¥¸¥ç¥ó̱»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥»¥é¥ô¥£¥Û¡¼¥ë¥Ç¥£¥ó¥°¥¹Ì±»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¥»¥Ü¥ó­ê̱»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
Ê¿À®21ǯ¡¡¥æ¡¼¥ê¡¼¥°­ê̱»öºÆÀ¸´ÆÆÄ°Ñ°÷
Ê¿À®22ǯ¡¡¥¨¥ë¡¦¥±¥¤»º¶È­ê¡¢­ë¥Ô¡¼¥µ¥¯¥»¥¹¡¢­ê¥¸¡¼¥¨¥ë³Æ̱»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥¤¥ó¥¿¡¼¥³¥ß¥å¥Ë¥±¡¼¥·¥ç¥ó¥ºÇË»º´Éºâ¿Í
Ê¿À®23ǯ¡¡­ê¥·¥Î¥Ï¥é̱»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­ê¥á¥É¾ë¼è̱»öºÆÀ¸¿½Î©ÂåÍý¿Í
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­êÆüËܴĶ­¥µ¡¼¥Ó¥¹ÇË»º´Éºâ¿Í

III. ²Ê³Øµ»½Ñ´Ø·¸¡Ê´©¹Ôʪ·ÇºÜ°Æ·ï¤«¤éÈ´¿è¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Î¤ß¡Ë
(1)Åìµþ¹âÅùºÛȽ½ê¡¡¾¼ÏÂ57ǯ10·î£µÆüȽ·è¡Ê¹âÅùºÛȽ½ê·º»öȽÎ㽸¡Ë
¡¡³ÐÀúޤÎÇ¢´ÕÄê¤Î¿®ÍÑÀ­¤¬Áè¤ï¤ì¤¿»öÎã
(2)Åìµþ¹âÅùºÛȽ½ê¡¡¾¼ÏÂ59ǯ12·î27ÆüȽ·è¡Ê¹âÅùºÛȽ½ê·º»öȽÎã¡ÊȽ·è¡Ë®Êó2772¹æ¡Ë
¡¡¸òÄÌ»ö¸Î´ÕÄê¤Î¿®ÍѤ¬Áè¤ï¤ì¡¢¿®Íê¤Î¸¶Â§¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿»öÎã